SB WILL BE CLOSED JULY 23 - 30, NO PICK-UPS OR DELIVERIES THOSE DATES! ------ We are currently only taking orders for items available in our online store. No custom orders. Please order online store items at least 1 week prior to your pick-up date. To add delivery to an order, add the Local Delivery item to your cart. Thanks!

All Items

Wanting something shipped to you? Check out our sister store, Storybook Bakery, Shipped! for items that we ship!

We do not currently ship from this site.

<--- Back to Categories

264 products
Alien Cookies (1 Dozen)
Alien Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
American Star Cookies (1 Dozen)
American Star Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Anchor Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Anchor Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Andy's Room Cake
Andy's Room Cake
$70.00
Andy's Toys Cookies (1 Dozen)
Andy's Toys Cookies (1 Dozen)
$45.00
Animal Face Cake
Animal Face Cake
$70.00
Art Palette Cookies (1 Dozen)
Art Palette Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Baby Onesie Cookies (1 Dozen)
Baby Onesie Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Baby Variety Cookies (1 Dozen)
Baby Variety Cookies (1 Dozen)
$45.00
Back-to-School Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Back-to-School Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$25.00
Bag of Coal Cookies
Bag of Coal Cookies
$15.00
Ball Gown Cookies (1 Dozen)
Ball Gown Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Baseball Cookies (1 Dozen)
Baseball Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Baseball Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Baseball Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Bat City Cake
Bat City Cake
$80.00
Big Bad Wolf Fudge
Big Bad Wolf Fudge
$15.00
Blank DIY Cookies (1 Dz)
Blank DIY Cookies (1 Dz)
$18.00
Blood Splatter Cupcakes
Blood Splatter Cupcakes
$35.00
Bridal Engagement Cookies (1 Dozen)
Bridal Engagement Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Building Blocks Cake
Building Blocks Cake
$75.00
Bunch of Hocus Pocus Cookies (1 Dozen)
Bunch of Hocus Pocus Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Burn Book Cake
Burn Book Cake
$75.00
Business Logo Cake
Business Logo Cake
$70.00
Buttercream Cakes - Customizable!
Buttercream Cakes - Customizable!
$75.00
Buttercream Piping Vintage Wedding Cake (3-tier)
Buttercream Piping Vintage Wedding Cake (3-tier)
$275.00
Cake Add-on: Animal Topper
Cake Add-on: Animal Topper
$20.00
Cake Add-on: Baby Shoes
Cake Add-on: Baby Shoes
$25.00
Cake Add-on: Crown
Cake Add-on: Crown
$12.00
Cake Add-on: Number Topper
Cake Add-on: Number Topper
$5.00
Calendar Cookies (1 Dozen)
Calendar Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Camo & Duty Game Cake
Camo & Duty Game Cake
$85.00
Candles
Candles
$2.50
Car Themed Cake
Car Themed Cake
$80.00
Catch 'Em All Cake
Catch 'Em All Cake
$70.00
Cauldron Cookies (1 Dozen)
Cauldron Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Celebration Cake
Celebration Cake
$55.00
Celebration Smash Cake
Celebration Smash Cake
$30.00
Chief Cap Cookies (1 Dozen)
Chief Cap Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Chocolate Covered Oreo Box
Chocolate Covered Oreo Box
$15.00
Chocolate Covered Oreos (1 Dozen)
Chocolate Covered Oreos (1 Dozen)
$20.00
Christmas Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Christmas Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Christmas Tree Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Christmas Tree Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Clipart Cake (Customizable)
Clipart Cake (Customizable)
$70.00
Cocoa Bomb & Mug Gift Set
Cocoa Bomb & Mug Gift Set
$15.00
Comic Book Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Comic Book Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Conversation Heart Cookies (1 Dz) - Naughty
Conversation Heart Cookies (1 Dz) - Naughty
$30.00
Conversation Heart Cookies (1 Dz) - Nice
Conversation Heart Cookies (1 Dz) - Nice
$30.00
Cookie Cakes
Cookie Cakes
$25.00
Cookie Cupcakes (NEW!)
Cookie Cupcakes (NEW!)
$18.00
Cookie Prescription Bag
Cookie Prescription Bag
$15.00 Sold out
Corset Lingerie Cookies (1 Dozen)
Corset Lingerie Cookies (1 Dozen)
$45.00
Cupcake Toppers (Bunch of Hocus Pocus)
Cupcake Toppers (Bunch of Hocus Pocus)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Construction Trucks)
Cupcake Toppers (Construction Trucks)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Dinosaurs)
Cupcake Toppers (Dinosaurs)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Dragons)
Cupcake Toppers (Dragons)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Horror Killers #2)
Cupcake Toppers (Horror Killers #2)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Horror Killers)
Cupcake Toppers (Horror Killers)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Mermaids)
Cupcake Toppers (Mermaids)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Pastel Dinosaurs)
Cupcake Toppers (Pastel Dinosaurs)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Puppies)
Cupcake Toppers (Puppies)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Shark Family)
Cupcake Toppers (Shark Family)
$6.00
Cupcake Toppers (Unicorns)
Cupcake Toppers (Unicorns)
$6.00
Cupcakes
Cupcakes
$30.00
Cupcakes - Drizzle (1 Dozen)
Cupcakes - Drizzle (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Cupcakes - Sprinkles (1 Dozen)
Cupcakes - Sprinkles (1 Dozen)
$30.00
Custom Cupcake Cake (2 Dz)
Custom Cupcake Cake (2 Dz)
$80.00
Custom Logo Cookies
Custom Logo Cookies
$30.00
Custom Photograph Cookies (1 Dozen)
Custom Photograph Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Custom Printed Gold Lettering Cookies (1 Dozen)
Custom Printed Gold Lettering Cookies (1 Dozen)
$30.00
Custom Theme Printed Cookies (1 Dozen)
Custom Theme Printed Cookies (1 Dozen)
$30.00
Customizable Cake Topper (Paper)
Customizable Cake Topper (Paper)
$12.00
Decorate-Your-Own Birthday Cake
Decorate-Your-Own Birthday Cake
$70.00
Dinosaur Cake
Dinosaur Cake
$75.00
Dinosaur Cake
Dinosaur Cake
$75.00
Dinosaur Cookies (1 Dozen)
Dinosaur Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Dinosaur Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Dinosaur Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
DIY Cookie Decorating Kit - September/October/November
DIY Cookie Decorating Kit - September/October/November
$30.00
DIY Holiday Cookie House Kit
DIY Holiday Cookie House Kit
$35.00 $30.00 Sale
DIY Holiday Cookie Kit
DIY Holiday Cookie Kit
$35.00
DIY Wedding Cake (1-tier)
DIY Wedding Cake (1-tier)
$50.00
DIY Wedding Cake (2-tier)
DIY Wedding Cake (2-tier)
$105.00
DIY Wedding Cake (3-tier)
DIY Wedding Cake (3-tier)
$225.00
Doll Dress Cake
Doll Dress Cake
$85.00
Donut Drip Cake
Donut Drip Cake
$75.00
Dots & Ruffles Mini Doll Cake
Dots & Ruffles Mini Doll Cake
$70.00
Dots/Stars Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Dots/Stars Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Dragon Cake
Dragon Cake
$75.00
Drip Cake
Drip Cake
$60.00
Easter Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Easter Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Elephant Polka Dot Cookies (1 Dozen)
Elephant Polka Dot Cookies (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Elf Cookie Sets
Elf Cookie Sets
$10.00
Emoji Cookies (1 Dozen)
Emoji Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Fairy Cakes
Fairy Cakes
$36.00
Fairy Fudge
Fairy Fudge
$15.00
Fairytale Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Fairytale Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Fall Turkey Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Fall Turkey Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Fishing Cake
Fishing Cake
$70.00
Flower Variety Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Flower Variety Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$35.00
FNAF Themed Drip Cake
FNAF Themed Drip Cake
$70.00
Football Cookies (1 Dozen)
Football Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Gingerbread Man Cookies
Gingerbread Man Cookies
$30.00
Gingerbread Man Cookies (6-count)
Gingerbread Man Cookies (6-count)
$17.50
Go Kart Racing Game Cake
Go Kart Racing Game Cake
$80.00
Golf Cake
Golf Cake
$70.00
Golf Cookies (1 Dozen)
Golf Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Graduation Cap Cookies (1 Dozen)
Graduation Cap Cookies (1 Dozen)
$45.00
Graduation Cookie Tray (2 Dozen)
Graduation Cookie Tray (2 Dozen)
$35.00
Graduation Gift Cookie Bag
Graduation Gift Cookie Bag
$15.00
Halloween Advent Cookie Calendar (Pre-Order)
Halloween Advent Cookie Calendar (Pre-Order)
$30.00
Halloween Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Halloween Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Happy Birthday Cards
Happy Birthday Cards
$6.00
Happy Holidays Cookie Bag
Happy Holidays Cookie Bag
$15.00
Hedgehog Game Themed Cake
Hedgehog Game Themed Cake
$75.00
Holiday Animals Cookies
Holiday Animals Cookies
$18.00
Holiday Cookie Stocking Stuffer Gift Box
Holiday Cookie Stocking Stuffer Gift Box
$10.00
Hot Cocoa Bomb - Customized (Single)
Hot Cocoa Bomb - Customized (Single)
$5.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (12 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (12 Pack)
$60.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (2 pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (2 pack)
$10.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (4 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (4 Pack)
$20.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (6 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Customized (6 Pack)
$30.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Fall Leaves (4 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Fall Leaves (4 Pack)
$20.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Fall Pumpkin (4 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Fall Pumpkin (4 Pack)
$20.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (12 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (12 Pack)
$54.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (4 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (4 Pack)
$18.00
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (6 Pack)
Hot Cocoa Bombs - Variety (6 Pack)
$27.00
House Cup-cakes
House Cup-cakes
$20.00
Jumbo Cupcake Cake
Jumbo Cupcake Cake
$45.00
Ladybug Cookies (1 Dozen)
Ladybug Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Lemon Belle Fudge
Lemon Belle Fudge
$15.00
Llama Cake
Llama Cake
$70.00
Local Delivery
Local Delivery
$15.00
Lump of Coal (Cocoa Bomb)
Lump of Coal (Cocoa Bomb)
$8.00
Magic Lamp Cookies (1 Dozen)
Magic Lamp Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Magic Wands (Pretzel Rods)
Magic Wands (Pretzel Rods)
$15.00
Make It Pink, Make It Blue Fudge
Make It Pink, Make It Blue Fudge
$15.00
Melon Baby Themed Cake
Melon Baby Themed Cake
$75.00
Melted Ice Cream Cone Drip Cake
Melted Ice Cream Cone Drip Cake
$70.00
Mermaid Cake
Mermaid Cake
$70.00
Mermaid Cupcakes
Mermaid Cupcakes
$40.00
Merry Christmas Cookie Bag
Merry Christmas Cookie Bag
$15.00
Military Emblem Printed Cookies (1 Dozen)
Military Emblem Printed Cookies (1 Dozen)
$30.00
Military Logo Cake
Military Logo Cake
$70.00
Military Retirement Cake
Military Retirement Cake
$75.00
Mini Apple Cookie Bags (5 Piece)
Mini Apple Cookie Bags (5 Piece)
$12.50
Mini Apple Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Apple Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Baby Onesie Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Baby Onesie Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Bone Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Bone Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Butterfly Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Butterfly Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Button Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Button Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Conversation Heart Cookies (2 Dz) - Naughty
Mini Conversation Heart Cookies (2 Dz) - Naughty
$25.00
Mini Conversation Heart Cookies (2 Dz) - Nice
Mini Conversation Heart Cookies (2 Dz) - Nice
$25.00
Mini Crown Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Crown Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Cupcakes
Mini Cupcakes
$20.00
Mini Dinosaur & Egg Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Dinosaur & Egg Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Fall Cookie Bags (5 Piece)
Mini Fall Cookie Bags (5 Piece)
$12.50
Mini Football Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Football Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Ghost Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Ghost Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Halloween Variety Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Halloween Variety Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Heart Cookies
Mini Heart Cookies
$25.00
Mini Heart Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Heart Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Holiday Cookie Bags
Mini Holiday Cookie Bags
$50.00
Mini Holiday Variety Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Holiday Variety Cookies (3 Dz)
$35.00
Mini Ladybug Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Ladybug Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Naughty Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Naughty Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Number/Letter Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Number/Letter Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Number/Letter Road Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Number/Letter Road Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Paw Print Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Paw Print Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Pumpkin & Leaf Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Pumpkin & Leaf Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Pumpkin Face Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Pumpkin Face Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Snowflake Cookies (3 Dz)
Mini Snowflake Cookies (3 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Star Cookies (4 Dz)
Mini Star Cookies (4 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Tire/Wheel Cookies (2 Dz)
Mini Tire/Wheel Cookies (2 Dz)
$25.00
Mini Variety Wedding Cookies
Mini Variety Wedding Cookies
$25.00
Mining Sword Cake
Mining Sword Cake
$75.00
Monster Truck Cake
Monster Truck Cake
$70.00
Muddy Puddle Pig Cake
Muddy Puddle Pig Cake
$70.00
Navy Chief Cake
Navy Chief Cake
$75.00
Nice List Cookie Bag
Nice List Cookie Bag
$15.00
Ninja Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Ninja Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$40.00
Number Cupcake Cake (2 Dz)
Number Cupcake Cake (2 Dz)
$70.00
Number or Letter Cookies (1 Dozen)
Number or Letter Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Ombre Cake
Ombre Cake
$60.00
Ombre Smash Cake
Ombre Smash Cake
$30.00
Personalized Gingerbread Boy/Girl Cookie (Jumbo)
Personalized Gingerbread Boy/Girl Cookie (Jumbo)
$10.00
Petal Cake
Petal Cake
$60.00
Pink Doll Themed Cake
Pink Doll Themed Cake
$70.00
Plaque Cookies (1 Dozen)
Plaque Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Polka Dots Girl Mouse Cake
Polka Dots Girl Mouse Cake
$70.00
Princess Crown Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
Princess Crown Paint-Your-Own Cookies (1 Dz)
$35.00
Princess/Prince Crown Cupcakes
Princess/Prince Crown Cupcakes
$40.00
Pumpkin Cookies (1 Dozen)
Pumpkin Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Pumpkin Roll (Whole or Sliced)
Pumpkin Roll (Whole or Sliced)
$15.00
Puppy Patrol Cake
Puppy Patrol Cake
$75.00
Rainbow & Flowers Cake
Rainbow & Flowers Cake
$75.00
Rainbow Cookies (1 Dozen)
Rainbow Cookies (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Rainbow Rosette Smash Cake
Rainbow Rosette Smash Cake
$35.00
Random Rosette Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Random Rosette Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
$35.00
Random Ruffle Cake
Random Ruffle Cake
$65.00
Ring Around the Roses Cake
Ring Around the Roses Cake
$60.00
Rose Cake
Rose Cake
$60.00