HOLIDAY UPDATE: Custom orders are closed through January 10th. Online store orders may be placed for pick-up dates through noon, Dec. 23rd. We will be closed from Dec. 23rd (at noon) - January 9th. Orders may be placed for orders with pick-up dates on/after Jan. 10th. Thanks!

Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake
Underwater Cake

Underwater Cake

Regular price $75.00 Sale

Under the Sea, darling it's better, down where it's wetter! Underwater Cakes are 4 layers of delicious from-scratch cake, filled with our silky-smooth Swiss Meringue Buttercream. Frosted in blue buttercream and decorated in underwater elements in your choice of colors and number topper. Variety of sizes and flavors available.

Note: Optional inscription will go on top and be done in bubble letters!

Cake should be ordered at least 1 week prior to your desired pick-up date. Please choose your pick-up date during checkout. We will email you 2-3 days prior to date to schedule pick-up time.

Note: Cookies not included but available in a separate listing.

Fairytale Flavor Combinations

(Cake & Filling - Outside Frosting is Vanilla)

Goldilocks - Butter Vanilla Cake & Vanilla Buttercream

White Witch - Butter Almond Cake & Almond Buttercream

Little Red Velvet Hood - Red Velvet Cake & Cream Cheese Frosting

Dark Queen - Chocolate Fudge Cake & Chocolate Buttercream

Fairy-berry - Butter Vanilla Cake & Strawberry Buttercream (no seeds!)

Pixie Dust - Rainbow Confetti Vanilla Cake & Vanilla Buttercream

Good vs. Evil - Chocolate Fudge Cake & Vanilla Buttercream

Dreamland - Orange Cake & Vanilla Buttercream

Banana Bo Peep - Banana Cake & Cream Cheese Frosting

Big Bad Wolf - Chocolate Fudge Cake & Cookies-N-Cream Buttercream

Evil Step-Mocha - Chocolate Fudge Cake & Mocha Buttercream

Princess & the Peanutbuttercream - Chocolate Fudge Cake & Peanutbuttercream